A landowner can withhold consent, but refusal does not prevent entry that BC Hydro is legally authorized to undertake. Section 20 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act permits BC Hydro to enter private land without consent for specified activities, including surveys, geotechnical testing, danger tree removal and construction of access roads.
The question arises along the North Coast Transmission Line when a crew enters a field, an access agreement arrives for signature, or a contractor proposes a road across private property. The answer depends on the legal authority for the proposed work and the rights BC Hydro already holds.
Entry under the Hydro and Power Authority Act and the Expropriation Act involves distinct powers and conditions. The distinction determines what notice an owner may receive, what activities are permitted and how compensation for damage is assessed. A separate question arises when BC Hydro seeks access beyond its existing rights.
What gives BC Hydro the right to enter private land without consent?
Section 20 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act permits BC Hydro to enter land without the owner’s consent to conduct surveys, make borings and trial pits, remove certain trees, and construct or use roads and other access facilities for specified statutory purposes.
The power is defined by its purpose rather than by the owner’s permission. Section 20(1) of the Hydro and Power Authority Act authorizes entry for purposes relating to the use, construction, maintenance, safeguarding or repair of BC Hydro’s plants or projected plants, or for better access to them. The reference to projected plants allows the power to operate before infrastructure is constructed.
Three categories of activity are identified. Paragraph (a) covers surveys, levels, borings, tests and trial pits, including geotechnical investigations. Paragraph (b) addresses trees that BC Hydro considers capable of endangering its infrastructure or obstructing survey lines. Paragraph (c) permits the construction or use of permanent or temporary roads, trails, bridges, wharves and other facilities required for convenient passage to and from survey lines, plants and projected plants.
Two features of the drafting carry practical weight. The provision refers to tests BC Hydro thinks necessary and trees that, in its opinion, may endanger its infrastructure. Those judgments must nevertheless be exercised within the scope and purposes of section 20. The section itself prescribes no advance notice period, daylight restriction or requirement for a written access agreement. Other applicable legal obligations or existing agreements may still affect a particular entry.
Does refusing consent have any legal effect?
Refusal does not remove a valid statutory power. Where the proposed activity exceeds section 20, BC Hydro must establish another lawful basis for entry, which may include an existing registered right of way, a negotiated agreement or powers under section 16 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act.
The effect of refusal depends on the proposed work. Where section 20 authorizes the activity, consent is not a prerequisite, and claims for resulting damage may arise under section 20(2).
Section 16 provides separate authority. Section 16(1)(b) permits BC Hydro to enter, remain on, take possession of and use property for purposes related to its statutory powers. Under section 16(3), ministerial approval is required before exercising a power under section 16(1) that does not constitute an expropriation of land requiring approval under the Expropriation Act. Section 16(8) also establishes compensation obligations for qualifying property use and resulting damage.
Physical interference raises another question. Preventing access that BC Hydro is lawfully entitled to exercise may lead to proceedings for injunctive relief. Where the authority or scope of entry is disputed, an owner should obtain legal advice before taking steps that may obstruct the work.
A petition filed in the Supreme Court of British Columbia on November 28, 2025, concerned alleged interference with access to properties near Vanderhoof along the Phase 1 corridor. BC Hydro relied in part on existing registered rights of way. The reported allegations are not judicial findings, and the final disposition has not been verified for this article.
Where a statutory right of way already encumbers a parcel, the registered instrument and plan must be examined to determine the rights granted. Those rights operate alongside any independent statutory powers available to BC Hydro. The broader framework is addressed in the North Coast Transmission Line landowner compensation guide.
How does entry under the Expropriation Act differ from section 20?
The Expropriation Act does not apply to an entry made under section 20 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act. Section 2(2)(d) expressly excludes that entry, meaning the daylight-hour restriction, notification requirements and six-month damage notice rule under section 9 do not automatically apply.
Section 9 of the Expropriation Act authorizes an expropriating authority to enter land for limited purposes before or after an expropriation notice or specified order is served. Entry must occur during daylight hours, after reasonable efforts to notify the owner or occupier.
Permitted activities include surveys, inspections, soil tests and examinations needed to establish the location of proposed works or describe the land intended for expropriation, together with appraisals. Section 9(2) also permits cutting trees or brush that obstruct survey lines.
Two subsections of the Expropriation Act protect the owner. Section 9(3) requires compensation for damage caused by the exercise of those entry powers. Where the entered land is not expropriated, section 9(4) prevents an action for that damage unless signed written notice is given to the authority within six months after entry. That notice requirement is distinct from any applicable limitation period for commencing proceedings.
Section 20 entry operates under a different regime. It contains no equivalent daylight restriction or six-month damage notice requirement. Compensation for damage arising under section 20 is governed by section 20(2) of the Hydro legislation.
Entry under section 20 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act compared with entry under section 9 of the Expropriation Act
| Feature | Section 20, Hydro and Power Authority Act | Section 9, Expropriation Act |
|---|---|---|
| Who may exercise the power | BC Hydro and authorized personnel, including contractors | Persons authorized by an expropriating authority |
| Owner’s consent | Not required | Not required |
| Notice before entry | None prescribed by section 20 | Reasonable efforts to notify |
| Permitted hours | None prescribed by section 20 | Daylight hours |
| Permitted purposes | Specified activities connected to plants, projected plants and access | Surveys, investigations and appraisals connected to expropriation |
| Roads and trails | Permanent or temporary access works under s. 20(1)(c) | No equivalent general road-construction power |
| Tree cutting | Danger trees and trees obstructing survey lines | Trees or brush obstructing survey lines |
| Compensation for damage | Section 20(2) | Section 9(3) |
| Notice before an action | No equivalent six-month notice rule | Signed written notice within six months where land is not expropriated |
| Who determines compensation | Supreme Court of British Columbia if not agreed | Supreme Court of British Columbia |
Which activities fall outside section 20 and require an agreement?
Section 20 expressly authorizes specified survey, testing, tree-cutting and access activities. Construction camps, material storage, laydown yards and workspace used for purposes beyond those activities require separate legal examination. They may depend on existing property rights, another statutory authority, a negotiated agreement or expropriation.
The distinction lies in the purpose of the proposed occupation. Section 20(1)(c) concerns works and facilities required for convenient passage to and from BC Hydro’s survey lines, plants and projected plants. A road used for that purpose differs from a construction compound occupied for equipment storage or accommodation.
That distinction does not establish that every activity outside section 20 necessarily requires an agreement. Section 16 may provide separate powers to enter and use property, subject to its requirements. Existing registered rights may also authorize activities beyond those expressly identified in section 20.
The following activities warrant separate examination:
- Temporary workspace for conductor stringing, splicing, assembly and crane operations
- Laydown and storage areas for fuel, materials, equipment and excavated material
- Construction camps, parking compounds, batch plants and helicopter landing areas
- Permanent access roads requiring an additional registered property interest
- Activities beyond the scope of existing rights or statutory entry powers
Where a parcel already carries a BC Hydro statutory right of way, the registered terms and plan determine the rights granted by that instrument. Work outside the registered area requires identification of another lawful basis, which may include statutory powers. The type and extent of occupation also affect the applicable compensation framework.
What compensation is available for damage caused by entry?
Section 20(2) provides for compensation for damage to crops, gardens, shrubs, trees or other growing things, together with other damage caused by or incidental to the exercise of section 20 powers. Where the amount cannot be agreed upon, compensation is determined by the Supreme Court of British Columbia.
The provision extends beyond vegetation damage. Depending on the circumstances, qualifying losses may include damage to fences, gates, culverts, drainage systems, agricultural land, roads and other improvements. The claimant must establish the damage and its connection to the exercise of statutory powers. Not every inconvenience, including dust, noise or temporary disruption, necessarily establishes a compensable loss.
Section 20 contains no counterpart to the six-month notice requirement in section 9(4) of the Expropriation Act. Other limitation periods may nevertheless apply. The Limitation Act generally establishes a two-year period from discovery for civil claims, subject to exceptions and other applicable statutory requirements. The deadline for a particular claim depends on its legal character and circumstances.
Evidence should be preserved when entry occurs. Dated photographs, property condition records, agricultural production figures, drainage plans, repair estimates and logs of equipment movements can assist in establishing causation and the extent of damage.
Compensation may also arise under section 16. Where BC Hydro exercises section 16 powers other than in relation to an expropriation of land, section 16(8) requires compensation for qualifying property interests or use and for damage directly resulting from the exercise of those powers. Disputed compensation under that subsection is determined by the Supreme Court under section 16(9).
Two further provisions shape liability. Section 30 addresses BC Hydro’s tort liability for specified conduct of its servants or agents and breaches of certain property-related duties. Section 31 limits liability in nuisance and under the rule in Rylands v. Fletcher unless BC Hydro was negligent. Neither provision automatically establishes compensation for every disturbance arising from lawful entry.
Where an agreement has been signed, its terms and any release must also be reviewed to determine the effect on subsequent claims.
What belongs in an access agreement?
An access agreement can establish negotiated conditions governing entry and may authorize activities beyond BC Hydro’s existing statutory rights. Its terms should identify the purpose and duration of access, contractors covered, notice requirements, working hours, property protection measures and compensation arrangements.
An agreement serves a function the statute does not necessarily perform. Section 20 identifies powers BC Hydro may exercise, but does not prescribe detailed arrangements for work on a ranch, cropped field, woodlot or property supporting livestock. Negotiated terms can address those practical matters and establish responsibilities for restoration and damage.
The terms that carry the most weight in an access agreement along the Phase 1 corridor include:
- Purpose, permitted work, the area shown on a plan, duration and renewal provisions
- Parties covered, including contractors and subcontractors, with insurance and indemnity obligations
- Advance notice, working hours, seasonal restrictions and access procedures
- Gates, locks, cattle guards, fencing and livestock protection
- Biosecurity, weed control, equipment cleaning and dust suppression
- Road construction, drainage, maintenance, decommissioning and restoration
- A pre-entry condition record with dated photographs
- Payment terms, responsibility for damage and express preservation of unresolved compensation claims
The final item requires particular care. An access agreement may contain settlement or release provisions affecting claims that would otherwise remain available, including future losses. The scope and enforceability of those provisions depend on their wording and the applicable law.
A temporary access agreement may also be negotiated alongside a permanent statutory right of way. The documents should be reviewed together to ensure that a release or payment provision in one does not unintentionally compromise claims arising under the other.
Advice on BC Hydro entry and access agreements
Entry questions are answered by identifying the legal authority relied upon, the activities proposed and any rights already registered against the title. ATAC LAW acts for landowners in expropriation and right of way matters, including disputes involving statutory entry, access agreements, compensation for property damage and the scope of contractual releases.
That work includes examining sections 16 and 20 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act, assessing proposed access arrangements, documenting damage and determining the applicable compensation procedure. The firm’s practice is described on its expropriation law page.
BC Hydro’s North Coast Transmission Line involves property acquisition, clearing, access-road construction and other preliminary works. Owners receiving access requests should establish the authority for the proposed work, record existing property conditions and review any agreement before execution. Those steps may affect the terms negotiated and the evidence available if damage or compensation later becomes disputed.
Frequently asked questions
Can BC Hydro enter land before serving an expropriation notice?
Yes. Section 20 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act authorizes entry for specified purposes without requiring an expropriation notice or the owner’s consent. Section 9 of the Expropriation Act separately allows qualifying entry before or after service of an expropriation notice or specified order, subject to its statutory requirements.
Does BC Hydro have to give notice before entering under section 20?
Section 20 itself prescribes no advance notice requirement or daylight-hour restriction. Those requirements arise under section 9 of the Expropriation Act, which does not apply to entry under section 20. Other applicable legal obligations or contractual arrangements may nevertheless affect notice in a particular case.
Can BC Hydro build a permanent access road across private land without an agreement?
Section 20(1)(c) authorizes BC Hydro to make or use permanent or temporary roads and other works required for convenient passage to and from its survey lines, plants or projected plants. That authority does not itself create a registered statutory right of way. A registered property interest requires a separate legal basis, generally through an agreement or expropriation. Section 16 may also authorize certain entry or use of property, subject to statutory requirements.
Who decides compensation for damage caused by survey or access work?
The Supreme Court of British Columbia determines compensation where the parties cannot agree under section 20(2) of the Hydro and Power Authority Act. The Court also determines disputed compensation under section 16(9) and compensation under section 9(3) of the Expropriation Act, through section 26(1)(b). The applicable provision depends on the authority exercised and the nature of the loss.
Landowners asked to provide survey access, permit geotechnical investigations, accommodate access roads or grant temporary workspace for the North Coast Transmission Line can contact ATAC LAW to arrange an appointment.


