Expropriation Law

Can Landowners Claim for BC Hydro Construction Damage After Signing a Right of Way?

Yes. Signing a right of way agreement does not necessarily settle damage caused during construction. The answer depends on the agreement, any release, the work that caused the damage and the legal basis for the claim.

Construction began on Phase 1 of the North Coast Transmission Line in summer 2026. BC Hydro targets fall 2030 for the line to enter service. Its construction updates describe clearing, access road work, bridge work and geotechnical investigations along parts of the corridor.

Those activities can damage crops, fences, soil and drainage. A landowner must distinguish compensation already paid for the right of way from losses caused by later work. Several legal routes may be available, and their requirements differ.

Does signing a right of way agreement end a claim for construction damage?

Usually, no. The payment for a right of way and compensation for later construction damage address different losses. The wording of the signed documents determines what was settled.

A right of way payment may account for the interest granted to BC Hydro and restrictions on the land’s use. It does not necessarily account for a fence damaged months later or a drain severed during road construction. An agreement can, however, address restoration and damage claims, and a release may settle more than the payment for the land interest.

The starting point is the executed right of way, any access or temporary workspace agreement, and any release. BC Hydro’s offer letter alone does not establish their terms. The broader acquisition process is discussed in the firm’s guide to North Coast Transmission Line landowner compensation rights.

Which damage the agreement answers, and which falls to statute

The registered right of way and any related agreement may impose repair or restoration duties. Statutory compensation may also be available for damage caused by work carried out under BC Hydro’s statutory powers.

Section 218 of the Land Title Act permits a statutory right of way without a dominant tenement. Its terms may appear in the registered instrument or in a filed set of standard charge terms incorporated into that instrument. Any modifications and schedules must also be reviewed. A covenant requiring restoration may provide a contractual basis for a claim if the work is left unfinished or damage is not repaired.

A release needs separate attention. Its effect depends on its wording and the circumstances in which it was signed. Some releases address compensation for the interest granted; others may extend to specified future claims. The firm’s guide to the BC Hydro right of way agreement examines terms that affect land use and compensation.

What section 20(2) of the Hydro and Power Authority Act covers

Section 20(2) addresses damage to crops and other growing things, as well as other damage caused by or incidental to BC Hydro’s exercise of its section 20 powers. If the amount is not agreed, the Supreme Court of British Columbia determines compensation.

Section 20(1) authorizes BC Hydro, through specified personnel and contractors, to enter land without the owner’s consent for purposes related to its plants or projected plants. The powers include surveys, tests, trial pits, certain tree cutting, and access works.

The words “other damage” in section 20(2) are not confined to crops or trees. Damage to soil, drainage or an access route may fall within the provision if it was caused by or incidental to an exercise of section 20 powers. The work performed and the source of BC Hydro’s authority must be established; the section does not automatically govern every activity on the parcel. The current Hydro and Power Authority Act sets out the powers and compensation provision.

When construction damage becomes a question of negligence

A negligence claim requires proof of a duty of care, a breach, causation and compensable loss. Section 30(2) of the Hydro and Power Authority Act addresses BC Hydro’s liability for torts of its servants and agents. Section 31 restricts nuisance and Rylands v. Fletcher claims against the authority unless it was negligent.

A section 20(2) claim focuses on damage connected to the exercise of that section’s powers and the amount payable. A negligence claim examines how the work was carried out. Site conditions, construction methods, supervision and the timing of a reported problem may matter.

Dust, vibration, noise and other interference can raise nuisance questions, but section 31 requires negligence for nuisance liability against BC Hydro. Physical damage may also support a negligence claim if its elements are proved. Liability of a contractor must be assessed separately. Tree removal beyond the corridor is discussed in the firm’s guide to danger tree removal outside the right of way.

Which route applies to which kind of damage

The source of the right to compensation determines what must be proved and which timing rule applies. The following routes depend on the documents and the statutory power used for the work.

Basis of claim Potential scope Who determines a dispute Timing
Right of way or related agreement Repair, restoration or payment obligations in the signed documents A court with jurisdiction, unless the parties resolve it Contract claims generally engage the Limitation Act’s two-year discovery period
Hydro and Power Authority Act, section 20(2) Growing things and other damage caused by or incidental to section 20 powers Supreme Court of British Columbia if compensation is not agreed The section states no express claim period; obtain advice promptly on the applicable limitation rule
Tort claim, including negligence Loss caused by a proven tort; section 31 restricts nuisance and Rylands v. Fletcher liability against BC Hydro A court with jurisdiction The Limitation Act’s two-year discovery period generally applies
Expropriation Act, section 9(3) Damage caused by an entry under section 9 for preliminary investigations Supreme Court of British Columbia under section 26(1)(b) If the land entered is not expropriated, section 9(4) requires signed written notice within six months after entry

These routes may overlap, but a loss cannot be recovered twice. The table is not exhaustive: section 16(8) of the Hydro and Power Authority Act may also require compensation when BC Hydro exercises powers under section 16(1) other than expropriation. Identifying the power actually used comes before selecting a claim.

What section 9 of the Expropriation Act adds, and the six month notice

Section 9 concerns entry for preliminary purposes such as surveys, inspections, soil tests and appraisals. It is not a general rule for damage caused by transmission line construction.

Section 9(3) provides for compensation for damage caused by an entry under that section. If the land entered is not expropriated, section 9(4) bars an action unless the claimant gives the expropriating authority signed written notice within six months after the entry. The requirement should be checked as soon as damage from preliminary work is found.

The Expropriation Act does not make that six-month notice period the deadline for every claim under a right of way agreement or section 20 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act. The firm’s guide to BC Hydro entry and access on private land addresses the distinction between statutory entry and agreed access.

Which records support a claim for construction damage

A useful record establishes the land’s condition before and after the work, when the change occurred, and which activity caused it. It should also support the amount claimed.

Owners should report damage promptly and preserve:

  • Dated photographs or video showing the location before, during and after work
  • Crop, yield and sale records, with suitable comparisons for unaffected land
  • Soil measurements and photographs of rutting, compaction or displaced topsoil
  • Drainage plans, culvert locations and dated evidence of new ponding
  • Fence and gate repair records, and records of any resulting livestock loss
  • Written reports to BC Hydro or its contractor, including the date, recipient and response

A damage report creates a contemporaneous record. It does not, by itself, replace any notice or court filing required for a particular claim.

Why damage across several construction seasons is more than one claim

Work may return to a parcel at different stages of construction. Separate incidents can have different causes, discovery dates and limitation periods.

Clearing, access work and tower construction may occur in different seasons. A later drainage failure may also reveal damage that was not apparent when equipment first crossed a field. Record each incident and its effects separately, while retaining evidence that links recurring problems to earlier work.

Waiting until the entire line is complete can put an earlier claim at risk. The firm’s guide to farm, ranch and timber land compensation addresses valuation issues affecting those properties.

Which deadline applies to a construction damage claim

There is no single deadline for all construction damage. The legal basis of the claim and the facts governing discovery must be assessed for each loss.

Section 6(1) of the Limitation Act generally requires a proceeding to begin within two years after a claim is discovered. Section 8 sets out what the claimant knew or reasonably ought to have known, including the loss, its cause, the person responsible and the appropriateness of a court proceeding. Section 3(2) addresses limitation periods established by another enactment.

For a qualifying section 9 entry claim, the signed written notice required by section 9(4) of the Expropriation Act is due within six months after entry if the land is not expropriated. Sections 41(3) and 42 establish a separate one-year filing rule for qualifying injurious affection claims involving land not taken or acquired. That rule should not be assumed to apply to a parcel on which BC Hydro has acquired a right of way.

Advice on BC Hydro construction damage claims

The signed documents, the power used to carry out the work, and the date and extent of each loss determine the available claim. ATAC LAW acts for landowners on right of way and expropriation matters, including construction damage, releases and disputed compensation. The firm’s expropriation law page describes that practice.

An early review can identify the applicable notice and limitation periods while site records remain available. Landowners can provide their agreements, photographs and damage reports through the firm’s contact page.

Frequently asked questions

BC Hydro has offered a payment for this season’s damage. What does accepting the payment settle?

It depends on the offer, any release and the circumstances of acceptance. Cashing a cheque marked “full and final” may be relied on as evidence of settlement. Review the wording before accepting payment, particularly if damage may emerge later.

Who pays the legal costs of a construction damage claim?

A settlement can specify costs. In litigation, the result, court rules and any applicable statutory costs provision determine what may be recovered. A costs award generally does not reimburse all legal fees.

Can neighbouring owners on the same construction segment bring their claims together?

Possibly. Rule 22-5(2) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules permits multiple parties where their proceedings would raise a common question or their claims arise from the same transaction or series of transactions. Each owner must still prove their own loss; the court may separate claims under Rule 22-5(6).

What if crews store materials or park equipment outside the right of way?

Check the right of way, any access or workspace agreement, and the statutory authority relied on. Section 20(1) contains broad entry powers, so use outside the granted area is not automatically trespass. Document the location, duration and resulting damage.

Who claims for crop damage on leased farmland, the owner or the tenant?

The Hydro and Power Authority Act’s definition of “owner” includes a lessee in possession for a term of three years or less. Who suffered the crop loss also depends on the lease and crop arrangements. The owner and tenant should identify their respective losses without claiming the same loss twice.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
bc hydro dam construction after cutting trees Expropriation Law

Can BC Hydro Cut Trees Outside the Right of Way? Danger Tree Removal and Landowner Compensation

Yes. Section 20(1) of the Hydro and Power Authority Act allows BC Hydro to enter land without the owner’s consent and cut…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
a landowner refuses BC Hydro transmission tower Expropriation Law

Can a Landowner Refuse BC Hydro Access? Entry, Surveys and Access Roads

A landowner can withhold consent, but refusal does not prevent entry that BC Hydro is legally authorized to undertake. Section 20 of…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
Landowners Should Review Before Signing a BC Hydro Right of Way Agreement Expropriation Law

What Landowners Should Review Before Signing a BC Hydro Right of Way Agreement

A BC Hydro right of way agreement may grant a statutory right of way under section 218 of the Land Title Act.…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator