Yes. Section 20(1) of the Hydro and Power Authority Act allows BC Hydro to enter land without the owner’s consent and cut down trees that, in its opinion, might endanger its conductors, wires, equipment or other plant. Section 20(2) provides a route to compensation for damage caused by the exercise of that power.
The question can arise along the North Coast Transmission Line when ribbons or paint marks appear on trees standing beyond the surveyed corridor. A registered right of way may show one boundary, while the proposed clearing extends beyond it. The difference matters: a registered charge and a statutory power of entry are separate sources of authority.
A statutory right of way sets out what BC Hydro may do under the terms of the registered charge. Section 20 stands apart from that charge and can apply where no right of way has been granted. BC Hydro also describes edge tree and hazard tree programs for managing vegetation near its lines. Those are operational descriptions; the authority for work on a particular parcel must be assessed against the charge, the statute and the proposed work.
Can BC Hydro cut trees that stand outside the right of way?
Yes. Section 20(1) is not confined to the area covered by a registered right of way.
BC Hydro may act through its engineers, surveyors, agents, contractors, subcontractors or employees. The entry must be for a purpose relating to the use, construction, maintenance, safeguarding or repair of its plants or projected plants, or for better access to them. For those purposes, section 20(1) permits entry on any land without the owner’s consent. It does not require a registered charge on that land.
This matters both to an owner whose right of way crosses only part of a parcel and to a neighbouring owner who has signed nothing. Neither should assume that the surveyed corridor is the outer limit of section 20. The terms of any charge still matter when identifying which authority BC Hydro is exercising and what compensation has already been addressed.
Consent, access agreements and statutory entry are examined further in the firm’s guide on refusing BC Hydro access to land.
What standard applies to a tree outside the corridor?
Section 20(1)(b) permits BC Hydro to cut down trees that, in its opinion, might, “in falling or otherwise,” endanger its conductors, wires, equipment or other plant. It also covers trees that may obstruct the running of survey lines.
The provision refers to BC Hydro’s opinion. It does not prescribe a particular distance from a line or require an independent arborist’s finding before the statutory power arises. A concern may involve more than a tree falling directly onto a wire: BC Hydro’s published guidance also identifies the electrical hazard that can arise when an object is close enough for an arc to form. The survey-line ground is distinct from the danger-to-plant ground.
The Act defines “plant” broadly, including works, installations, apparatus and equipment used or potentially usable in connection with generating or supplying power. That definition informs the scope of the danger described in section 20(1)(b). It does not remove the section’s purpose requirement or the need to identify the trees and work actually at issue.
Section 20(2) addresses compensation for damage caused by or incidental to the exercise of section 20 powers. Section 30 also addresses BC Hydro’s liability in tort, subject to the limits elsewhere in the Act. An owner concerned about proposed clearing should document the trees and the surrounding land before work begins. The firm’s North Coast Transmission Line landowner guide addresses that record in the broader acquisition process.
How do right of way clearing, edge trees and hazard trees differ?
The location and authority for the work matter more than the program name. Clearing within a registered right of way may be governed by its charge terms. Work beyond it may require consideration of section 20.
BC Hydro describes its edge tree program as managing trees along transmission corridors and its hazard tree program as managing trees with damaged roots, disease or other defects that could cause them to fall on distribution lines, equipment or buildings. Its guidance on planting and logging near rights of way also cautions against planting tall or weak-rooted trees outside a right of way where they might fall on lines or structures. BC Hydro’s program bulletin describes the two programs.
| Type of work | Location | Authority and compensation to examine |
|---|---|---|
| Right of way clearing | Within the registered area | The registered charge and any applicable statutory power; the charge terms and payment arrangements |
| Edge tree work | Along a transmission corridor, potentially beyond the registered area | Section 20 where BC Hydro relies on that power; compensation for resulting damage under section 20(2) |
| Hazard tree work | Near lines or equipment, potentially on neighbouring land | Section 20 where its conditions are met; compensation for resulting damage under section 20(2) |
| Trees obstructing survey lines | On the route being surveyed | The survey-line ground in section 20(1)(b); compensation for resulting damage under section 20(2) |
| Trees on land expropriated by BC Hydro | Within land taken under section 16 | The applicable expropriation and compensation provisions |
The categories can overlap on the ground. A tree’s program label alone does not establish the legal basis for removing it, and an owner cannot recover twice for the same loss. Sections 16 and 20 have different compensation provisions; the Expropriation Act applies when land is expropriated under section 16.
Is compensation payable for trees cut outside the right of way?
Section 20(2) expressly addresses claims for damage to trees and other growing things, as well as other damage caused by or incidental to the exercise of section 20 powers. If the amount is not agreed, the Supreme Court of British Columbia determines it.
The provision also names crops, gardens and shrubs. Depending on the evidence, a clearing operation may give rise to a claim involving damaged fencing, ground, drainage or access as well as the trees themselves. The damage and its connection to the exercise of section 20 must be established.
A section 20 claim should be considered separately from payment for granting a right of way over the same parcel. The right of way payment concerns a defined registered interest; section 20(2) concerns damage arising from the exercise of statutory powers. The documents and the loss claimed must be reviewed to avoid overlooking an item or counting it twice.
Section 2(2)(d) of the Expropriation Act states that the Act does not apply in respect of an entry under section 20 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act. Its procedures for an expropriation therefore should not be assumed to govern a section 20 damage claim. Compensation for an acquired right of way is discussed in the firm’s guide on how BC Hydro right of way compensation is calculated.
How is the value of trees cut under section 20 established?
Section 20(2) identifies the damage for which a claim may be made and the court that determines a disputed amount. The amount depends on evidence of the actual loss; the section does not prescribe one valuation method for every tree.
Merchantable timber, a shelterbelt and ornamental screening may call for different evidence. Timber records may address species, volume, grade and marketability. The function of a shelterbelt or screen may require evidence of its condition, location and effect on the property. The appropriate measure must be assessed in the circumstances, including any overlap between a claim for the trees and a claim concerning the land.
An owner facing proposed clearing can assemble:
- Dated photographs showing the trees in place and their location relative to the line and surveyed corridor
- A count and available records of species, size and condition
- Records explaining any timber, agricultural, screening or other property use
- Existing arborist, forestry, survey or appraisal records
- Notices, plans and correspondence describing the proposed work
- Photographs of fencing, drainage, ground and access routes before entry
Where part of a parcel is also expropriated, section 40(1)(b)(i) of the Expropriation Act may address a reduction in the market value of the remaining land, subject to that section’s requirements. Section 30(3) preserves the limitations on compensation in section 121 of the Forest Act where they apply. These provisions require separate attention on working timber land. The firm discusses that setting in its guide on compensation for farms, ranches and timber land.
What can a neighbouring owner claim after signing nothing?
A neighbouring owner may have a section 20(2) claim for damage caused by the exercise of section 20 powers even without a right of way agreement. A separate claim for loss in property value requires its own legal assessment.
Section 20 does not require an earlier agreement between BC Hydro and the owner. If BC Hydro exercises that power on neighbouring land, the owner can seek compensation under section 20(2) for damage within its terms.
A decline in property value does not, by itself, establish a claim for injurious affection. Section 41 of the Expropriation Act concerns injurious affection where no land is taken, but it preserves entitlement only to the extent that the applicable law recognizes it. The cause of the loss, the nature of the interference and the authority for the work must be examined. If section 41 applies, section 42 requires a written application to the court with particulars within one year after the damage was sustained or became known to the person suffering it. The statute bars a claim that is not made in accordance with that requirement.
Section 31 of the Hydro and Power Authority Act also restricts an action against BC Hydro based on nuisance or the rule in Rylands v. Fletcher unless BC Hydro was negligent. Section 30(2) addresses certain tort liabilities. Neither provision makes every loss of a treed view or screen compensable. The firm examines the separate entitlement question in its guide on compensation where BC Hydro takes no land.
What happens when clearing recurs over the life of the line?
Section 20(1) includes maintenance and safeguarding among its purposes. It is not limited to a single entry. Damage from later work must be assessed on the facts of that work and against any agreement or release the owner has signed.
Trees remaining after construction may be assessed again as they grow or their condition changes. BC Hydro describes its vegetation management as ongoing, and its North Coast Transmission Line construction page provides project information. A record of the first clearing does not replace photographs and measurements of a later operation.
The wording of a right of way agreement or release matters. An owner should identify the registered charge terms and read any proposed settlement against the work already performed and the possibility of later clearing. The firm addresses those documents in its guide on reviewing a BC Hydro right of way agreement before signing.
Advice on BC Hydro danger tree removal and compensation
ATAC LAW acts for landowners in expropriation and right of way matters. Where trees are marked beyond a corridor, the immediate questions are which authority BC Hydro relies on, which trees it proposes to remove and what evidence is needed to document the loss. The firm’s expropriation law page describes its practice in this area.
For owners along the North Coast Transmission Line, review is particularly useful while marked trees remain standing. Their location, condition and use can then be recorded, the proposed work can be clarified, and the effect of any agreement or release can be assessed before it is signed.
Frequently asked questions
Will BC Hydro tell an owner before removing a hazard tree?
BC Hydro says it contacts property owners to discuss hazard-tree work on their land before starting. That published practice should be distinguished from the wording of section 20, which permits entry without the owner’s consent and does not itself set out a general advance-notice procedure for tree cutting. If trees have been marked without an explanation, the owner can ask BC Hydro to identify the proposed work and its basis in writing.
Can an owner ask BC Hydro to prune a marked tree instead of removing it?
Yes. An owner can ask for the assessment and discuss pruning or another workable measure before clearing. That request does not give the owner a veto over a properly exercised statutory power. BC Hydro says trees are removed when necessary after consideration, but the appropriate treatment depends on the tree and the risk it presents.
What if the trees have already been cut and there are no photographs from before the work?
The claim may be harder to prove, but other records may still help: BC Hydro’s plans and work records, earlier photographs, surveys, forestry or farm records, stump measurements and photographs taken immediately afterward. An owner should also document damage to ground, drainage, fencing and access before repairs obscure it.
Does section 20 set a deadline for making a tree-damage claim?
Section 20(2) does not state a claim deadline. That should not be treated as permission to delay: a limitation period may apply depending on the claim and the procedure used. The one-year rule in section 42 of the Expropriation Act specifically concerns a claim under section 41(3) for injurious affection where no land is taken; it should not be presented as the deadline for every tree-damage claim. Prompt advice is important when both types of loss may be alleged.
Should an owner sign a clearing consent or compensation release before the work?
The document should be reviewed for the land and trees it covers, the payment offered, and the claims it releases. Particular care is needed if its wording extends to future maintenance or damage beyond the immediate clearing. Signing may affect what the owner can claim later; the answer depends on the document’s terms.
Landowners with trees flagged, cut or scheduled for clearing on or beside the North Coast Transmission Line can contact ATAC LAW to arrange an appointment.


