The Supreme Court of British Columbia refused to terminate a commercial lease after a tenant nearly doubled a Surrey building’s footprint without the required permits and extended the structure onto a neighbouring right-of-way. Although the construction breached an implied term of the lease, the Court found that the tenant had not refused to correct the violations. In Pakistan-Canada Association Inc. v. Great Light Healing Ministries Int’l: City of Faith, 2026 BCSC 1976, the landlord’s refusal to cooperate with remediation efforts was relevant to the Court’s decision.
How Unauthorized Construction Led to a Lease Dispute
Pakistan-Canada Association Inc. leased its Surrey property to Great Light Healing Ministries beginning in 2013. Between 2020 and 2021, the tenant renovated and expanded the building, nearly doubling its original footprint without obtaining the required municipal permits. The addition encroached onto a neighbouring railway right-of-way, and the City of Surrey subsequently identified building and occupancy permit violations.
The landlord sought to terminate the lease, arguing that the unlawful construction constituted a fundamental breach. In an earlier judgment, the Court found that the tenant had breached an implied obligation to perform improvements lawfully, but that the breach did not justify termination. After losing its appeal in June 2025, the landlord brought another petition, alleging that the tenant’s continued failure to correct the violations had become grounds for termination.
When Does a Lease Breach Justify Termination?
The Court distinguished between an ordinary contractual breach, a breach of a true condition and a fundamental breach. A breach of a true condition may justify termination based on the parties’ intentions when entering the contract, while a fundamental breach concerns conduct that deprives the innocent party of substantially the benefit of the agreement. Not every serious contractual breach satisfies these requirements.
The earlier judgment established that performing renovations lawfully was an implied lease obligation, but its breach did not deprive the landlord of the substantial benefit of receiving rent in exchange for the tenant’s use of the premises. The judge nevertheless observed that a subsequent refusal to correct the unlawful construction could potentially justify termination. The renewed proceedings therefore focused on the tenant’s efforts to remedy the violations rather than the original construction alone.
Why the Tenant’s Remediation Efforts Mattered
Following the earlier judgment, the landlord demanded that the tenant rectify the violations or remove the unlawful addition. Although the tenant did not provide the requested remediation summary and schedule, it had consulted professionals, communicated with the City and investigated ways to resolve the encroachment. The Court found that these efforts contradicted the landlord’s allegation that the tenant had refused to correct the problems.
The tenant also approached BC Hydro, which controlled the adjoining right-of-way, about obtaining permission for the encroachment to remain. BC Hydro was considering a possible licence but required soil testing before assessing the proposal further. The tenant obtained a testing proposal and paid an $11,200 deposit, but testing could not proceed because the landlord refused the necessary consent.
The landlord had also declined an earlier request for authorization needed to pursue municipal permits and had failed to promptly disclose correspondence received from the City. Justice Walker found that the landlord’s conduct and the absence of further municipal direction had impeded the tenant’s remediation efforts. Although the construction remained unlawful, the evidence did not establish that the tenant had refused to remedy the violations.
Why the Court Refused to Terminate the Lease
The Court concluded that the tenant’s continued failure to complete remediation did not constitute a fundamental breach because the landlord had not been deprived of the substantial benefit of the lease. It also rejected the argument that the circumstances established a breach of a true condition entitling the landlord to terminate. The petition was dismissed, with costs awarded to the tenant.
The Court did not determine whether the landlord had originally authorized the renovations or establish that it was legally obligated to cooperate with remediation. However, even assuming no such obligation existed, the landlord’s refusal to provide necessary consent remained relevant to assessing the alleged refusal to correct the violations. The distinction between an inability to complete remediation and an actual refusal to remedy the breach was central to the decision.
What Commercial Landlords and Tenants Should Take From the Decision
Unauthorized construction can constitute a serious lease breach without necessarily providing grounds for immediate termination. Landlords seeking termination should document the violations, communicate clear remedial demands and assess the tenant’s actual response. Refusing consent or withholding information necessary for remediation may undermine an allegation that the tenant has refused to correct the problem.
For tenants, the decision highlights the importance of maintaining records of permit applications, professional consultations, correspondence and attempts to correct unlawful improvements. Lease provisions governing prior approval, permit responsibilities and remedial obligations also deserve careful attention. ATAC LAW advises commercial landlords, tenants and property owners on commercial leasing and commercial litigation, including disputes involving unauthorized improvements, lease defaults and termination.


