Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Builder Could Not Remove CPL Blocking Sale of Nearly Completed Home

The Supreme Court of British Columbia refused to cancel a certificate of pending litigation (CPL) registered against a nearly completed residential development in Parksville, despite evidence of financial hardship, disrupted financing and a blocked property sale. In Walkinshaw v. Departure Bay Construction Ltd., 2026 BCSC 1913, the Court found that the builder had not established that its hardship was caused solely by the CPL rather than the underlying litigation. The decision examines the requirements for cancelling a CPL and why financial security may be inadequate when a claimant seeks physical compliance with restrictions affecting land.

How the Construction Dispute Began

Departure Bay Construction Ltd. purchased a residential lot in Parksville intending to construct and sell a home. The company built a main residence containing a suite and a separate two-bedroom carriage house on property subject to a registered statutory building scheme. A neighbouring property owner alleged that the development breached restrictions permitting only single-family dwellings and requiring a minimum ground-floor area.

The neighbour also alleged that the builder had failed to construct a drainage swale required under a registered drainage agreement. She commenced proceedings seeking compliance with the building scheme, removal of the carriage house and construction of the drainage swale. She also registered a CPL against the property while pursuing those claims.

Why the Builder Sought to Remove the CPL

Construction was approximately 95% complete when the neighbour commenced litigation and registered the CPL. The builder reported that its bank refused to release the final construction draw, requiring it to obtain more expensive unsecured financing. It also maintained that the resulting financial difficulties prevented further development activity and led to worker layoffs.

The property had received an occupancy permit and attracted an offer to purchase, conditional on removing the CPL. The builder argued that the registration prevented it from completing the sale and repaying outstanding debts. It applied under section 256 of the Land Title Act to cancel the CPL and offered $100,000 in security to protect the neighbour’s claim.

Why Financial Hardship Was Not Enough

Under sections 256 and 257 of British Columbia’s Land Title Act, a property owner may seek cancellation of a CPL based on hardship and inconvenience caused by its registration. The hardship must be real and non-trivial, but establishing financial difficulty does not automatically justify cancellation. The applicant must demonstrate that the hardship is causally connected solely to the registration, rather than the underlying litigation.

Justice Young accepted that the builder had suffered hardship but found that the required causal connection had not been established. Although the CPL notified the lender and prospective purchaser of the litigation, it remained unclear that either would proceed if the registration were removed. The unresolved allegations concerning compliance with the building scheme could themselves affect the property’s financing and sale.

The Court therefore concluded that the builder had not proven that the CPL alone caused its hardship. The existence of the underlying litigation remained a potential independent obstacle to financing and completing the sale. Evidence of substantial financial consequences was insufficient to establish the necessary causal connection.

Why $100,000 in Security Was Insufficient

Section 257 permits cancellation of a CPL on security where the Court is satisfied that damages would provide adequate relief to the party who registered it and that security is appropriate. The builder offered $100,000, but the neighbour was seeking more than financial compensation. Her claim sought physical compliance with the building scheme, including removal of the carriage house and construction of the drainage swale.

The Court was not satisfied that monetary security would adequately protect that claim. Even if the neighbour could recover damages following a sale, she would remain beside buildings she alleged were non-compliant. The Court therefore refused to cancel the CPL in exchange for the proposed security.

What the Court Did Not Decide

The Court did not determine that the builder had breached the statutory building scheme. Justice Young acknowledged ambiguities in the restrictions governing single-family dwellings and left their interpretation for trial. The Court also identified an unresolved issue concerning the positive obligation to construct the drainage swale and whether that obligation could run with the land.

The application to cancel the CPL was dismissed, as was the builder’s request for an undertaking as to damages and related security from the neighbour. The underlying claims concerning the buildings and drainage obligations remained unresolved. Costs of the application were awarded to the neighbour in the cause.

What Builders and Developers Should Take From the Decision

A CPL can disrupt construction financing and prevent a property sale, but those consequences do not automatically justify cancelling its registration. Builders seeking cancellation must establish that the registration itself caused the required hardship and address the remedies pursued in the underlying litigation. Where a claimant seeks physical compliance with land restrictions, monetary security may not provide an adequate substitute.

The decision also highlights the importance of reviewing registered building schemes, restrictive covenants and drainage agreements before commencing construction. An occupancy permit and substantial construction completion do not resolve private disputes concerning land-use restrictions. ATAC LAW represents builders, developers and property owners in construction litigation and real estate disputes, including proceedings involving CPLs, restrictive covenants and development-related property rights.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
commercial space renovation lease dispute Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Can a Landlord Terminate a Lease Over Illegal Renovations? B.C. Court Rejects Termination Bid

The Supreme Court of British Columbia refused to terminate a commercial lease after a tenant nearly doubled a Surrey building’s footprint without…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
commercial foreclosure redemption period Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Can a Forbearance Agreement Shorten the Usual Six-Month Foreclosure Period? B.C. Court Says Yes

The Supreme Court of British Columbia granted a one-month redemption period and conduct of sale in a commercial foreclosure involving approximately $2.09…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
bc builder home sale specific performance Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Builder Ordered to Complete $845,000 Home Sale Five Years Later Despite Defects and Informal Contract

The Supreme Court of British Columbia ordered a builder to complete the sale of a newly constructed home for $845,000 plus GST,…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator