Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Can a Forbearance Agreement Shorten the Usual Six-Month Foreclosure Period? B.C. Court Says Yes

The Supreme Court of British Columbia granted a one-month redemption period and conduct of sale in a commercial foreclosure involving approximately $2.09 million in debt. In Business Development Bank of Canada v. Citra Logistics Ltd., 2026 BCSC 1970, the Court gave considerable weight to a forbearance agreement expressly providing for both remedies. The decision shows that equity in mortgaged property does not necessarily justify the usual six-month redemption period after borrowers receive additional time to repay.

What the Borrowers Agreed To

Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC) loaned Citra Logistics Ltd. $2 million, secured by a mortgage over two vacant industrial properties near Prince George and other security. BDC demanded repayment in June 2025 and entered a forbearance agreement with Citra and other respondents on July 11, 2025. It agreed to postpone enforcement until January 11, 2026, absent an earlier default.

In return, the respondents consented to an order nisi with a maximum one-month redemption period, expressly reducing the usual six months to account for the forbearance. They also agreed to an immediate conduct-of-sale order if repayment was not made. The agreement expired without repayment, and the amount owing at the September 2026 hearing was $2,091,789.96, including protective disbursements.

Why the Borrowers Asked for Six Months

The respondents argued that the properties were valuable enough to protect BDC against a shortfall. They relied on a February 2022 appraisal of $4.89 million and July 2025 assessments totalling approximately $2.76 million. They said they intended to refinance or sell but could not complete those steps within one month.

Associate Judge Shirreff accepted that the valuation evidence suggested BDC was likely to be repaid, although the older appraisal warranted caution. The refinancing evidence was vague, with no concrete details of steps taken to obtain financing or sell the properties. By the hearing, the borrowers had been in default for approximately 15 months, including more than eight months after the agreement expired.

Why the Court Followed the Agreement

The Court confirmed that foreclosure remedies are equitable and a forbearance agreement cannot displace judicial discretion over the redemption period. Nevertheless, the agreement’s terms must be weighed alongside the other evidence and circumstances. Here, the respondents expressly accepted a one-month period rather than merely promising not to oppose foreclosure.

The Court found that the agreement, the time already available to repay and the lack of concrete refinancing evidence favoured the shorter period despite potential equity. It also recognized that uncertainty over negotiated forbearance terms could discourage lenders from granting additional time. The Court therefore exercised its discretion consistently with the parties’ agreement.

Why Conduct of Sale Was Ordered Concurrently

The Court granted conduct of sale without requiring a separate application after the redemption period. It relied on the express agreement and found no reasonable risk of materially changed circumstances during the short interval. The Court fixed October 26, 2026, as the redemption deadline, with conduct of sale effective October 27, 2026.

The Court also confirmed that the borrowers could seek an extension of the redemption period if they satisfied the applicable legal test. The judgment did not establish that the properties had been sold or determine their final market value. Any dispute concerning the priority of other registered charges was left for later determination if necessary.

What Commercial Borrowers and Lenders Should Take From the Decision

A borrower agreeing to a shortened redemption period makes a consequential concession, particularly where refinancing remains speculative. Lenders should set out the agreed redemption and sale provisions precisely while recognizing that the Court retains discretion. Both parties should document concrete refinancing or sale efforts rather than relying on general intentions or dated valuations.

ATAC LAW represents lenders, borrowers and commercial property owners in real estate litigation and commercial disputes. Its work includes secured-lending disputes and enforcement of contractual obligations involving commercial property. The firm assesses the terms of the financing agreements alongside the evidence and available remedies.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
bc builder home sale specific performance Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Builder Ordered to Complete $845,000 Home Sale Five Years Later Despite Defects and Informal Contract

The Supreme Court of British Columbia ordered a builder to complete the sale of a newly constructed home for $845,000 plus GST,…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
bc dam repair liability Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Court Rules Province Had No Duty to Warn Property Buyers of Alleged Dam Defects

The British Columbia Court of Appeal upheld the striking of a negligence claim against the Province for allegedly failing to warn property…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
BC resulting trust moether son home ownership right Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Mother Paid $1.2 Million for Home in Son’s Name: B.C. Court Orders Transfer

A mother who paid the entire $1.2-million purchase price of a Coquitlam home remained its beneficial owner, despite registering the property in…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator