Litigation and Dispute Resolution

Who Controls a Corporate Shareholder’s Proxy? B.C. Court Refuses Independent Chair in Ignite Board Dispute

The Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed an application to appoint an independent chair for a contested shareholder meeting at Ignite International Brands Ltd. In Small Ventures USA, LP v. Ignite International Brands, Ltd., 2026 BCSC 2155, the Court considered conflicting voting instructions from a corporate shareholder’s director and controlling shareholder. Justice Loo held that Ignite was obliged to recognize the proxy issued through the corporation’s authorized governance structure.

Why Shareholders Sought an Independent Chair

Three petitioners holding approximately 1.9% of Ignite’s voting shares sought an independent chair for a special meeting scheduled for October 1, 2026. The meeting included resolutions to remove incumbent directors, reduce the board to three members and appoint replacements. The petitioners relied on alleged irregularities at Ignite’s December 2025 annual general meeting to support their application.

The dispute concerned Atlas Investments Ltd., which owned approximately 11.5% of Ignite’s shares. Atlas’s sole director, Gregory Gilpin-Payne, issued a proxy supporting the incumbent nominees. Roger Ver, who owned more than 99.99% of Atlas, separately instructed that the shares should not be voted.

Why the Corporate Director’s Proxy Controlled

Ver emailed his instructions to Gilpin-Payne, copying Ignite’s meeting chair and the individual who became Atlas’s proxy holder. Nevertheless, the director-issued proxy was never revoked, and the proxy holder voted in accordance with it. The petitioners argued that Ignite should have recognized Ver’s contrary instructions given his controlling ownership of Atlas.

Justice Loo rejected that argument, emphasizing the distinction between corporate ownership and management. Atlas’s affairs were managed through its director, not directly by its shareholders, regardless of their ownership percentage. Ignite was therefore obliged to rely on the director-authorized proxy and had no demonstrated duty to investigate the disagreement.

The judgment does not prevent controlling shareholders from changing corporate voting arrangements through proper governance procedures. However, Ver’s personal instructions did not revoke the existing proxy. Any effective change required action through Atlas’s corporate authority.

Why Roger Ver’s Exclusion Was Not Improper

The petitioners also challenged Ver’s exclusion from the December 2025 meeting. Ignite’s articles permitted corporate shareholders to appoint individuals as meeting representatives, but there was no evidence that Atlas had appointed Ver. His ownership of Atlas did not independently entitle him to attend Ignite’s meeting on its behalf.

The Court also observed that Ver’s attendance would not have changed how Atlas’s shares were voted. The appointed proxy holder had acted according to the existing proxy. Consequently, the exclusion did not establish the alleged impropriety.

Why the Court Refused an Independent Chair

Under section 186 of British Columbia’s Business Corporations Act, courts have jurisdiction to make orders concerning shareholder meetings. However, appointing an independent chair requires evidence of potential impropriety by the proposed chair. The assessment is forward-looking and focuses on the anticipated conduct of the upcoming meeting.

The petitioners relied on the alleged mishandling of Atlas’s votes at the earlier meeting. Justice Loo found no impropriety in accepting the authorized proxy or excluding Ver without a corporate appointment. The Court also noted that a senior solicitor from Ignite’s corporate counsel would assist the chair at the upcoming meeting.

The petitioners failed to establish a sufficient risk of future impropriety. The Court dismissed the application and awarded costs against the petitioners at Scale B. It did not determine the outcome of the proposed director election.

Implications for Corporate Governance

The decision highlights the importance of corporate authority in proxy voting and shareholder representation. Corporate secretaries and meeting chairs should verify proxy appointments and revocations through the appropriate corporate processes. A controlling shareholder’s personal instructions do not automatically override an existing corporate proxy.

ATAC LAW represents companies, directors and shareholders in commercial litigation and shareholder disputes and advises on corporate governance and commercial matters. These matters may involve voting rights, director appointments and urgent court applications. The firm advises on governance disputes and related proceedings before British Columbia courts.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
RBC closet indexing class action Litigation and Dispute Resolution

RBC “Closet Indexing” Class Action Expands to Examine Benchmark Risk and Active-Management Fees

The Supreme Court of British Columbia has allowed two additional questions to be decided in an existing class action alleging that RBC…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
mareva injuction property sales in BC Litigation and Dispute Resolution

When Property Sales Justify a Mareva Injunction: Two B.C. Rulings in a Franchise Dispute

The Supreme Court of British Columbia granted a freezing order against three individual defendants in a franchise dispute involving a $466,166.80 claim.…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
crypto mining data centre hosting dispute Litigation and Dispute Resolution

A Cryptocurrency Hosting Contract Is Not an Uptime Guarantee: B.C. Court Dismisses Mining-Facility Claim

A cryptocurrency-mining company failed in its lawsuit against a British Columbia data-centre operator after alleging that promised hosting capacity and services were…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator