Litigation and Dispute Resolution

When Property Sales Justify a Mareva Injunction: Two B.C. Rulings in a Franchise Dispute

The Supreme Court of British Columbia granted a freezing order against three individual defendants in a franchise dispute involving a $466,166.80 claim. In 1194432 B.C. Ltd. v. Gram Canada Investment Ltd., 2026 BCSC 2183, the Court found that property dispositions and other circumstances created a real risk that a future judgment could not be enforced. In a subsequent decision, 2026 BCSC 2184, the injunction was maintained after two defendants challenged it.

How the Franchise Dispute Led to an Asset Freeze

The plaintiff entered into an agreement with Gram Canada Investment Ltd. to operate a pancake franchise in Vancouver. It alleged that the franchisor supplied a disclosure document so deficient that it amounted to no disclosure under the Franchises Act. The plaintiff sought statutory rescission, refunds and compensation from the franchisor and individuals alleged to be franchisor’s associates.

Default judgments obtained against the franchisor and three individual defendants were subsequently set aside. One individual listed her property before the judgments were set aside and sold it in July 2026, while two others listed properties afterward. The plaintiff sought a Mareva injunction without notice to prevent asset dispositions that could frustrate enforcement.

What Evidence Justified the Freezing Order?

A Mareva injunction is an extraordinary remedy restricting dealings with assets before final judgment. An applicant must establish a strong prima facie or good arguable case, with the Court then considering the balance of convenience and risks to enforcement. The first ruling identified several relevant considerations.

Consideration Evidence
Strength of claim Strong prima facie statutory rescission case
Identifiable assets Residential property interests held by three defendants
Disposition risk One property sold; two others listed for sale
Enforcement concerns Limited information about other assets and concerns about litigation conduct

Justice Walker found the statutory claim sufficiently strong to support interim relief. The timing and circumstances of the property transactions supported an inference that the defendants were attempting to avoid satisfying a potential judgment. The Court also accepted a real risk of non-recovery and found the balance of convenience favoured the injunction.

Why the Injunction Survived the Challenge

In the second proceeding, two defendants challenged the injunction, arguing that the plaintiff had omitted potentially adverse British Columbia authority when applying without notice. The dispute concerned the distinction between deficient franchise disclosure and disclosure so inadequate that it legally amounts to no disclosure. This distinction affects the availability of the Franchises Act’s 60-day and two-year rescission periods.

The Court rejected the argument that the omitted authority required the injunction’s discharge. Following de novo reconsideration, the Court maintained the freezing order. Proof of a specific intention to defeat judgment was not required where the evidence established a sufficient risk that asset dispositions would undermine enforcement.

What Businesses Should Take From These Decisions

Businesses seeking emergency asset protection should preserve evidence of their claims, identifiable assets, proposed transactions and potential enforcement difficulties. Applicants proceeding without notice must disclose material facts and relevant adverse legal authorities. Defendants can challenge the supporting evidence, disclosure and proportionality of the order.

Neither decision finally determined the validity of rescission, personal liability or compensation. The litigation remained scheduled for trial beginning October 25, 2027. ATAC LAW represents businesses and individuals seeking or defending Mareva injunctions and urgent relief through its commercial litigation practice.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
RBC closet indexing class action Litigation and Dispute Resolution

RBC “Closet Indexing” Class Action Expands to Examine Benchmark Risk and Active-Management Fees

The Supreme Court of British Columbia has allowed two additional questions to be decided in an existing class action alleging that RBC…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
shareholder boardroom Litigation and Dispute Resolution

Who Controls a Corporate Shareholder’s Proxy? B.C. Court Refuses Independent Chair in Ignite Board Dispute

The Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed an application to appoint an independent chair for a contested shareholder meeting at Ignite International…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
crypto mining data centre hosting dispute Litigation and Dispute Resolution

A Cryptocurrency Hosting Contract Is Not an Uptime Guarantee: B.C. Court Dismisses Mining-Facility Claim

A cryptocurrency-mining company failed in its lawsuit against a British Columbia data-centre operator after alleging that promised hosting capacity and services were…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator