The Supreme Court of British Columbia has allowed two additional questions to be decided in an existing class action alleging that RBC Global Asset Management Inc. charged active-management fees while its Canadian Equity Fund closely tracked a market index. In McCorquodale v. RBC Global Asset Management Inc., 2026 BCSC 2142, Justice Elwood permitted the plaintiffs to expand the certified common issues. The Court did not find that RBC engaged in closet indexing, misled investors or charged excessive fees.
What Is the Allegation Against RBC?
The Canadian Equity Fund is an actively managed mutual fund benchmarked against the S&P/TSX Capped Composite Total Return Index. Active managers select and weight investments to pursue the fund’s objectives, typically charging higher fees than index funds, which seek to track a benchmark. “Closet indexing” describes the alleged practice of charging for active management while following an index closely.
The plaintiffs claim that the fund’s performance was so closely linked to its benchmark that investors paid more for management services than those services justified. The Court noted that the fund outperformed its benchmark before fees in 14 of the 20 years reviewed, from 2005 to June 2025. Certain fund series also outperformed after fees in some periods but not others.
What Two Questions Did the Court Add?
The class action was certified in 2021 with 16 common issues. The plaintiffs later amended their pleadings to expressly disclaim fraud and sought to add two questions: Was the fund’s before-fee performance substantially linked to its benchmark because of low active risk? Was there a substantial risk it would not outperform the benchmark after fees?
Active risk measures differences between a fund’s performance and its benchmark attributable to active management decisions. A close statistical relationship may be relevant to the plaintiffs’ case, but it does not, by itself, prove that the managers deliberately tracked the index. The Court observed that proof of the alleged intentional closet-indexing strategy would still require evidence of a plan to do so.
Why Were the New Questions Allowed?
At this stage, the plaintiffs needed to demonstrate some basis in fact that the proposed questions could be resolved collectively and advance the litigation. They did not need to prove wrongdoing. The plaintiffs relied on Professor Mikhail Simutin’s analysis of active share, tracking error and performance correlation, while RBC relied on evidence that genuine active management can produce returns resembling a benchmark.
Justice Elwood found an adequate evidentiary foundation for both questions without resolving the competing expert opinions. Crucially, the Court identified a gap in the plaintiffs’ evidence concerning the standards for adequate disclosure and reasonable fees. Those merits questions will require appropriately qualified expert evidence.
Could Investors Recover Excess Management Fees?
The plaintiffs propose comparing the fees charged by RBC with representative index-fund fees to measure alleged overpayment. They do not assert that every investor would have switched to an index fund if given different disclosures. The Court accepted that comparison as a workable component of a class-wide loss methodology, while recognizing that individual damages and causation issues may remain.
Canadian regulators have not established a minimum active-risk level to justify a particular fee, nor is there an express rule requiring disclosure of the risk of underperforming a benchmark after fees. The plaintiffs nevertheless allege that contractual, fiduciary and general prospectus disclosure obligations were breached. Those allegations have not been decided.
What Remains to Be Decided?
The two new questions can be resolved alongside the existing common issues, including claims concerning management practices and disclosure obligations. A finding of low active risk or underperformance risk would not, on its own, establish liability. The decision permits those questions to proceed to the merits stage; it does not establish a new industry-wide rule for mutual funds.
ATAC LAW represents parties in securities and investor disputes and commercial litigation. The firm advises on disputes involving investment representations, contractual obligations and financial losses.


