Litigation and Dispute Resolution

Who Holds the Passwords Holds the Business: B.C. Court Fines Former Director in Digital-Account Dispute

The Supreme Court of British Columbia fined a former company director for failing to surrender access credentials to online accounts central to a media business. In Singh v. Sandhu, 2026 BCSC 2152, the Court found that providing limited Cloudflare access did not satisfy an injunction requiring specific account credentials. Justice Ormiston imposed a $5,000 fine and a further conditional fine of $10,000 to encourage compliance.

How Digital Accounts Became the Focus of a Shareholder Dispute

FYI Media Group Ltd. distributes Punjabi- and Hindi-language content through television and social media. Tirath Singh and Sukhwinder Sandhu were among its three original equal shareholders; after the third shareholder transferred his shares to Sandhu, Sandhu became the majority shareholder. Singh ceased being a director in January 2024, while Sandhu became the sole director.

Singh subsequently claimed a 50% ownership interest and disputed control of the business. The parties agreed that FYI Media’s online accounts were its primary assets, providing access to revenue, its brand and its client base. Several accounts were in Singh’s personal name, making access credentials a central issue in the litigation.

What the Injunction Required

In December 2024, FYI Media obtained an injunction requiring Singh to supply credentials for its GoDaddy account and five specified social-media accounts. Those were FYI Media’s Facebook and YouTube accounts, Sangha TV’s Facebook and YouTube accounts, and News Only’s YouTube account. The injunction also restricted Singh’s dealings with clients, use of company-domain email and representations that he was authorized to act for FYI Media.

Singh was found in contempt in January 2025 for failing to comply, with punishment initially suspended to allow compliance. He then provided access through Cloudflare, which he argued was functionally sufficient for GoDaddy. He also maintained that his brother controlled the social-media credentials and that he could not provide them.

Why Cloudflare Access Did Not Satisfy the Order

Justice Ormiston found that Cloudflare access did not provide the control required by the injunction. Without the GoDaddy credentials, FYI Media could not perform functions such as renewing its domain, updating its website or administering certain company email accounts. Singh acknowledged that his proposed access left him with a measure of control that the company lacked.

The Court also refused to vary or cancel the original injunction. Such an application required a material change to the facts underlying the order, not a fresh argument about its merits. Singh’s revised account of who held the social-media passwords conflicted with his earlier representations and did not establish the necessary change.

What the Court Ordered

Justice Ormiston imposed a $5,000 fine payable immediately for the existing contempt. A further $10,000 fine would apply if Singh failed to provide the specified GoDaddy and social-media credentials within 30 days of the order. The Court declined to grant judgment on FYI Media’s counterclaim as a contempt sanction because factual disputes still required determination.

FYI Media also asked the Court to compel GoDaddy to provide access information directly. Although GoDaddy did not oppose the request, the Court dismissed that application with leave to reapply if compliance was not forthcoming; applications concerning other platforms were adjourned generally. The Court considered existing injunctive relief and the newly imposed contempt sanctions preferable to compulsory third-party disclosure at that stage, and awarded the defendants costs on the ordinary scale, payable forthwith.

What Businesses Should Take From the Decision

Companies that rely on domains, email and social-media platforms should maintain company-controlled registrations, secure inventories of credentials and more than one authorized administrator. Shareholder agreements and director-departure procedures should address who can administer accounts and how access will be transferred. These safeguards may reduce operational disruption when ownership or management is disputed.

The Court did not decide Singh’s claimed ownership interest or finally determine who was entitled to the contested digital assets. Its ruling addressed compliance with an existing interim order and the consequences of contempt. ATAC LAW represents parties in commercial litigation and shareholder disputes and advises on corporate governance, including disputes involving control of business assets.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
RBC closet indexing class action Litigation and Dispute Resolution

RBC “Closet Indexing” Class Action Expands to Examine Benchmark Risk and Active-Management Fees

The Supreme Court of British Columbia has allowed two additional questions to be decided in an existing class action alleging that RBC…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
shareholder boardroom Litigation and Dispute Resolution

Who Controls a Corporate Shareholder’s Proxy? B.C. Court Refuses Independent Chair in Ignite Board Dispute

The Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed an application to appoint an independent chair for a contested shareholder meeting at Ignite International…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
mareva injuction property sales in BC Litigation and Dispute Resolution

When Property Sales Justify a Mareva Injunction: Two B.C. Rulings in a Franchise Dispute

The Supreme Court of British Columbia granted a freezing order against three individual defendants in a franchise dispute involving a $466,166.80 claim.…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator