Construction Law

Later Hardware Activity Did Not Extend the Builders’ Lien Deadline: B.C. Court Cancels Supplier Liens

The Supreme Court of British Columbia cancelled builders’ liens filed against a 132-unit Vancouver condominium development after finding that the statutory filing period had expired. In Ulmus (OKU) Development Ltd. v. Accurate Door & Hardware Company Ltd., 2026 BCSC 2174, the Court found the residences ready for their intended use no later than June 4, 2026. Disputed hardware activity after that date did not establish a later completion date.

The Project Close-Out Timeline

Date Event
April 15 and 28, 2026 Occupancy permits issued for two buildings
June 4, 2026 Final occupancy permit; latest completion date found by the Court
June 15 and July 16, 2026 Disputed deliveries or collections of hardware
July 31, 2026 Liens filed, 57 days after June 4

Accurate supplied doors and hardware to a three-building condominium development. No certificate of completion had been issued, and the project had no head contractor. Accordingly, section 20(2)(b) of the Builders Lien Act made completion of the improvement the relevant trigger for the 45-day filing period.

What Established the Completion Date?

Under section 1(3) of the Builders Lien Act, an improvement is completed when it, or a substantial part of it, is ready for use or being used for its intended purpose. For this development, the intended purpose was residential occupation. An occupancy permit provides evidence of readiness but does not automatically establish the completion date.

The developer’s CEO stated that the units were complete apart from minor deficiencies by June 4. The Court accepted that evidence, supported by the occupancy permits and conveyances of some units to purchasers. Justice Klein found the development ready for its intended use no later than June 4 without treating the permits alone as conclusive.

Why Later Hardware Activity Did Not Extend the Deadline

Accurate’s operations manager described materials allegedly delivered on June 15 and July 16, including doors, electric strikes and smaller hardware items. The developer disputed those deliveries and described certain materials as replacement or warranty items collected from Accurate. The Court did not resolve every disagreement about the materials.

Accurate also relied on hearsay evidence suggesting that trades continued working after June 4. However, it provided no meaningful evidence explaining how the later work or materials prevented residential use of any units. The Court found that this evidence did not undermine the developer’s account of project readiness.

Why the Court Cancelled the Liens

The Court found that the July 31 filings occurred after the 45-day statutory period had expired. It ordered cancellation under section 25 of the Builders Lien Act and awarded costs to the petitioners. It did not determine the amount owed, resolve the competing formulations of the applicable evidentiary threshold, or decide the alleged defects in the lien forms.

What Contractors and Developers Should Take From the Decision

Later deliveries, deficiency work and warranty replacements do not necessarily extend the lien-filing period. Suppliers should identify the applicable statutory deadline and preserve evidence showing how outstanding work affects an improvement’s intended use. Developers seeking cancellation should retain completion records, occupancy documents and conveyancing evidence rather than relying exclusively on permit dates.

ATAC LAW represents contractors, suppliers and developers in construction law and construction litigation. Its lawyers advise on builders’ lien filing deadlines, lien cancellation and disputed construction payments. Early assessment is important when statutory deadlines or pending property transactions require immediate action.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
bc renovation payment lawsuit builders lien cpl Construction Law

Six Years of Inaction Leads to Dismissal of B.C. Builders’ Lien Action and CPL Cancellation

The Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed a contractor’s renovation-payment lawsuit after more than six years without litigation progress. In White Hart…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
construction consultant liability waiver case Construction Law

Does an Owner’s Liability Waiver Protect Subconsultants? B.C. Court of Appeal Says Not Necessarily

The British Columbia Court of Appeal has upheld a decision denying a lower-tier construction consultant the protection of an owner’s contractual waiver…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
builder lien holdback construction payment dispute Construction Law

Provincial Court is No Place for Builders Lien Claims

The British Columbia Court of Appeal overturned orders striking construction payment claims and staying a separate builders-lien holdback claim because of overlapping…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator