Construction Law

Six Years of Inaction Leads to Dismissal of B.C. Builders’ Lien Action and CPL Cancellation

The Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed a contractor’s renovation-payment lawsuit after more than six years without litigation progress. In White Hart Homes Ltd. v. Ewert-Johns, 2026 BCSC 2107, the Court found the delay inordinate and inexcusable and concluded that allowing the action to continue was not in the interests of justice. It separately ordered cancellation of a certificate of pending litigation (CPL) that had restricted the homeowners’ access to property equity.

How the Renovation Dispute Became Dormant

White Hart Homes Ltd. registered a $35,979.69 builders’ lien against a Bowen Island property in May 2019. In May 2020, it sued for $42,414.05 in unpaid invoices, unspecified contractual damages and other relief, and registered a CPL. The homeowners counterclaimed, alleging overcharging, deficient work and misconduct.

Pleadings closed in July 2020, but neither party advanced document discovery, examinations for discovery or trial scheduling. No further court documents were filed until the homeowners applied in September 2026 to dismiss the action and cancel the CPL. The Court considered this period of inactivity inordinate.

Why Litigation Costs Did Not Excuse the Delay

Under Giacomini Consulting Canada Inc. v. The Owners, Strata Plan EPS 3173, 2023 BCCA 473, the Court considered whether the delay was inordinate, whether it was inexcusable and whether proceeding nonetheless served the interests of justice. White Hart argued that defending the homeowners’ counterclaim made litigation too expensive relative to its claim. Justice Shergill found the delay deliberate and tactical, without reliable evidence demonstrating financial hardship.

White Hart provided no litigation plan or evidence that it was ready to proceed. The Court also noted that less costly options had not been explored and that the homeowners had no obligation to advance the contractor’s claim. Memories could fade, documents might be lost, and the CPL had prevented the homeowners from accessing property equity for business purposes.

The Court dismissed White Hart’s claim for want of prosecution under Rule 22-7(7) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules. The homeowners consented to dismissal of their counterclaim, leaving the underlying payment and deficiency allegations undecided. Costs were left for agreement or further application.

Why the CPL Was Cancelled Separately

Dismissal of the action did not automatically cancel the CPL. The Court ordered cancellation under section 252 of the Land Title Act because no step had been taken in the proceeding for more than one year and White Hart failed to satisfy its burden against cancellation. Alternatively, the Court found cancellation supported under section 256 by hardship and inconvenience caused by the CPL’s effect on borrowing.

The registered builders’ lien was separate from the CPL. The homeowners abandoned their application to remove the lien itself. Accordingly, the Court made no order concerning cancellation of that registration.

What Contractors and Property Owners Should Take From the Decision

Starting a builders’ lien lawsuit does not shield it indefinitely from dismissal for inactivity. Contractors should advance proceedings, retain evidence and substantiate genuine barriers to prosecution. Owners affected by dormant CPLs may seek statutory cancellation even where the underlying claim was never tried.

ATAC LAW represents contractors and property owners in construction law and construction litigation involving builders’ liens, payment disputes and title-related remedies. The firm assesses litigation history, statutory requirements and the effects of encumbrances on financing. Its lawyers represent parties enforcing construction claims and those defending delayed proceedings.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
construction consultant liability waiver case Construction Law

Does an Owner’s Liability Waiver Protect Subconsultants? B.C. Court of Appeal Says Not Necessarily

The British Columbia Court of Appeal has upheld a decision denying a lower-tier construction consultant the protection of an owner’s contractual waiver…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
builder lien holdback construction payment dispute Construction Law

Provincial Court is No Place for Builders Lien Claims

The British Columbia Court of Appeal overturned orders striking construction payment claims and staying a separate builders-lien holdback claim because of overlapping…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
Patullo bridge engineering arbitration Surrey, BC Construction Law

Pattullo Bridge Arbitration: B.C. Court Refuses Appeal of $4.94 Million Design Award

The British Columbia Court of Appeal refused a contractor’s application to appeal an arbitration award arising from engineering design errors on the…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator