Construction Law

Does an Owner’s Liability Waiver Protect Subconsultants? B.C. Court of Appeal Says Not Necessarily

The British Columbia Court of Appeal has upheld a decision denying a lower-tier construction consultant the protection of an owner’s contractual waiver of claims, despite language referring to “all other consultants.” In Tru-Line Technologies Ltd. v. Fraser Health Authority, 2026 BCCA 408, the Court found no reversible error in interpreting that phrase as limited to consultants retained directly by the design-builder. The decision examines how contractual definitions, supplementary conditions and project responsibilities determine who benefits from liability waivers.

How the Construction Dispute Began

Fraser Health Authority retained VanMar Constructors 1043 Inc. under a modified CCA 14 design-build contract to construct a long-term care facility in Mission, British Columbia. VanMar contracted with Trilar Fire Protection to design and construct the fire suppression system, and Trilar subsequently retained Tru-Line Technologies Ltd. for consulting services. Tru-Line was therefore a lower-tier consultant without a direct contractual relationship with VanMar or Fraser Health.

In January 2020, a sprinkler line in the facility’s attic allegedly cracked, causing water damage. Fraser Health commenced proceedings against Tru-Line and another company, alleging negligence and breach of contract relating to the sprinkler system. Tru-Line applied for summary judgment dismissing the claim, arguing that the design-build contract’s waiver protected it from Fraser Health’s claims.

Why the Waiver Did Not Protect Tru-Line

General Condition 12.2.1 of the design-build contract included a waiver releasing the design-builder, designated consultant, “all other consultants,” subcontractors and suppliers from certain claims, subject to specified exceptions. Tru-Line argued that the broad wording protected every consultant involved in the project, regardless of who retained them. Fraser Health maintained that the protection extended only to consultants engaged directly by VanMar.

The Court acknowledged that “all other consultants” was broad when read in isolation. However, the contract’s definitions of consultants, subcontractors and suppliers emphasized direct contractual relationships with the design-builder. Reading the waiver in the context of those provisions supported limiting its protection to directly retained consultants.

The supplementary conditions also influenced the interpretation because they modified the standard-form contract’s allocation of risk. One indemnification clause replaced “all other consultants” with “Sub-Consultants,” while the owner’s indemnification clause and waiver retained the original terminology. The Court considered these differences, together with the modified insurance provisions, as supporting the narrower interpretation.

Why the Contractual Structure Mattered

The design-build agreement placed comprehensive responsibility for the project on VanMar, including supervision and control of the work performed by consultants and subcontractors. The Court found that the agreement distinguished directly retained participants from consultants engaged further down the contractual chain. This distinction was consistent with limiting the owner’s waiver to parties having direct contractual relationships with VanMar.

The Court also considered the commercial implications of extending protection to lower-tier consultants. Fraser Health had no direct contractual relationship with Tru-Line and no meaningful contractual ability to supervise its work. Extending the waiver to Tru-Line would have been inconsistent with the allocation of responsibility reflected in this particular agreement.

Why the Exception to Privity Did Not Apply

Tru-Line alternatively relied on the principled exception to privity of contract, which may allow third parties to enforce contractual protections intended for their benefit. Under the test established in Fraser River Pile & Dredge Ltd. v. Can-Dive Services Ltd., the contracting parties must have intended to extend the relevant benefit to the third party. Because Fraser Health and VanMar had not intended their waiver to protect consultants in Tru-Line’s position, the Court found that this requirement was not satisfied.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding no palpable and overriding error in the chambers judge’s interpretation of the modified contract. The decision did not determine whether Tru-Line was negligent or responsible for the alleged sprinkler failure. It addressed only whether Tru-Line could rely on the waiver to obtain dismissal of Fraser Health’s claim.

What Construction Consultants Should Take From the Decision

Lower-tier consultants should not assume that liability waivers in a prime contract extend to them merely because the wording appears broad. Contractual definitions, supplementary conditions and the allocation of responsibility between project participants may restrict those protections. Consultants should ensure their own agreements expressly address liability waivers, indemnities, insurance and claims brought by project owners.

ATAC LAW advises engineers, architects, contractors and other construction professionals on construction contracts and risk allocation and construction litigation. Its work includes reviewing supplementary conditions, contractual liability provisions and the allocation of risk among project participants. The firm also represents parties in disputes concerning construction defects, professional responsibility and contractual interpretation.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
builder lien holdback construction payment dispute Construction Law

Provincial Court is No Place for Builders Lien Claims

The British Columbia Court of Appeal overturned orders striking construction payment claims and staying a separate builders-lien holdback claim because of overlapping…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
Patullo bridge engineering arbitration Surrey, BC Construction Law

Pattullo Bridge Arbitration: B.C. Court Refuses Appeal of $4.94 Million Design Award

The British Columbia Court of Appeal refused a contractor’s application to appeal an arbitration award arising from engineering design errors on the…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
cost plus construction contract dispute in BC Construction Law

A Cautionary Tale of Cost-Plus Contracting

The Supreme Court of British Columbia found that homeowners fundamentally breached a cost-plus construction contract by withholding $87,625.70, representing most of the…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator