Litigation and Dispute Resolution

Undisclosed Grow Operation: B.C. Court of Appeal Upholds Wawanesa’s Denial of Fire Coverage

The British Columbia Court of Appeal upheld Wawanesa’s refusal to cover fire damage to an Abbotsford home after an undisclosed marijuana grow operation was discovered in a separate building on the property. Although the fire apparently started from a prayer candle inside the residence, the grow operation was found to constitute a material change in insurance risk. In Kallu v. The Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company, 2026 BCCA 385, the Court confirmed that requesting the removal of a building from insurance coverage did not satisfy the obligation to disclose the underlying risk.

Why Wawanesa Denied the Fire Claim

Parveen and Gurvinder Kallu purchased an Abbotsford property in 2015, consisting of a family residence and an approximately 1,800-square-foot outbuilding located about 200 feet away. Their Wawanesa homeowners’ insurance policy covered both structures and was renewed in 2016 and 2017. In March 2018, a fire damaged the main residence, and an insurance adjuster subsequently discovered a marijuana grow operation in the outbuilding.

Wawanesa denied coverage on the basis that the owners had failed to disclose a material change in risk. The owners maintained that they were unaware of the operation and had previously requested removal of the outbuilding from their policy. The trial judge rejected their claim and found that Wawanesa was justified in refusing coverage for the fire damage.

Why the Grow Operation Was a Material Risk

The trial judge rejected the owners’ evidence that they knew nothing about the grow operation. Based on the physical evidence and other circumstances, including their previous licences to grow marijuana, the Court found that they had established the operation after purchasing the property. The judge also accepted underwriting evidence that a grow operation, even if no longer operating, presented material risks involving fire, mould, water damage and theft.

The owners argued that the operation was located in a separate building, away from the residence where the fire occurred. However, the trial judge accepted evidence that the physical separation did not eliminate the increased insurance risk. Wawanesa’s underwriting manager testified that the insurer would not insure properties containing marijuana grow operations, and the owners presented no contrary evidence on materiality.

Why Removing the Outbuilding From Coverage Was Not Enough

The owners relied on a June 2017 form requesting removal of the outbuilding from their insurance policy. The form identified the reason for the request as a leaking building but made no mention of the grow operation. The trial judge found that the requested change had never been completed because the form had not reached Wawanesa’s underwriting department.

The outbuilding remained expressly covered under the policy, and the owners continued paying the same premiums. On appeal, the owners argued that providing the form to their insurance broker satisfied the requirement to notify the insurer or its agent. The Court of Appeal rejected this argument because the form did not disclose the material risk, even assuming the broker could be treated as Wawanesa’s agent.

What the Insurance Act Requires

Under section 29 of British Columbia’s Insurance Act, statutory condition 4 requires insureds to promptly notify their insurer or its agent in writing of a material change in risk within their knowledge and control. If the required notice is not provided, the insurance contract is void as to the part affected by that change. The obligation concerns disclosure of the actual material risk, not merely a request to change the scope of coverage.

The Court of Appeal emphasized that the trial judge’s findings concerning the owners’ knowledge, the materiality of the operation and their failure to disclose it were not challenged on appeal. Those findings were sufficient to uphold Wawanesa’s refusal to cover the fire damage. The appeal therefore turned on the established material risk and nondisclosure, not on whether the outbuilding had been successfully removed from coverage.

What Property Owners Should Take From the Decision

The judgment demonstrates that an undisclosed material change in risk can affect insurance coverage for damage occurring elsewhere on the insured property. For homeowners, landlords and commercial property owners, changes in property use should be assessed against the policy’s disclosure requirements, particularly where the activities may affect an insurer’s underwriting decision. The relevant questions include the nature of the change, its materiality and the insured’s knowledge and control.

Property owners should ensure that written notices accurately describe material changes rather than relying on general requests to amend or reduce coverage. Communications through an insurance broker should identify the actual risk, and owners should confirm that requested policy amendments have been completed. ATAC LAW represents individuals and businesses in civil litigation and commercial disputes, including disputes involving contractual obligations and financial losses.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
shareholder oppression commercial property Litigation and Dispute Resolution

Directors Personally Exposed After $5.5 Million in Property-Sale Proceeds Diverted to Related Businesses

The Supreme Court of British Columbia found shareholder oppression after controlling directors directed more than $5.5 million in commercial property-sale proceeds toward…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
novo textile receivership industrial architecture Litigation and Dispute Resolution

An Unsigned Sale Did Not Prevent Receivership in $9.55 Million Default, B.C. Court Rules

The Supreme Court of British Columbia appointed a receiver over a medical-mask manufacturer and three related companies despite ongoing negotiations for a…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
Patullo bridge engineering arbitration Surrey, BC Construction Law

Pattullo Bridge Arbitration: B.C. Court Refuses Appeal of $4.94 Million Design Award

The British Columbia Court of Appeal refused a contractor’s application to appeal an arbitration award arising from engineering design errors on the…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator