The Supreme Court of British Columbia found shareholder oppression after controlling directors directed more than $5.5 million in commercial property-sale proceeds toward their own business interests instead of redeeming a retiring business owner’s preferred shares. In Johnson v. Blackstock, 2026 BCSC 1944, the Court found that the directors misused their corporate control, personally benefited and acted in bad faith. The decision illustrates how shareholder redemption arrangements and promises concerning property-sale proceeds can establish reasonable expectations protected under corporate law.
How the Shareholder Dispute Began
David Johnson owned a Chilliwack Harley-Davidson dealership through his holding company, 659581 B.C. Ltd. In 2015, he sold the dealership business through a vendor-financed transaction while retaining interests in the company holding its commercial properties. As part of his retirement plans, Johnson subsequently exchanged those interests for redeemable preferred shares through restructurings in 2020 and 2023.
Cameron Blackstock and Peter Murie gained control of the property-holding company through these arrangements, with limited upfront cash expenditure. Johnson’s holding company received preferred shares redeemable on demand within 30 days. He expected the company’s real estate assets, or proceeds from their eventual sale, to fund redemption of those shares.
What Happened to the Property-Sale Proceeds?
Between December 2023 and July 2025, the company sold three commercial properties, generating more than $6.5 million in net proceeds. Approximately $1 million was paid to Johnson’s holding company, in addition to continuing monthly payments, while more than $5.5 million went to the controlling respondents and their related businesses. The company’s remaining property had an assessed value of approximately $9.8 million but was encumbered by a mortgage exceeding $11.5 million.
The respondents argued that transferring funds to their other businesses helped maintain operations and meet financial obligations. However, the Court found that they had preferred their own business interests over the petitioners’ share-redemption rights. They had also failed to provide proper financial disclosure concerning the company and its property transactions.
Why the Court Found Shareholder Oppression
Under section 227 of British Columbia’s Business Corporations Act, shareholders may seek relief where corporate affairs are conducted oppressively or unfairly prejudicially. Courts assess the shareholder’s reasonable expectations objectively, considering the parties’ agreements, representations, relationships and commercial circumstances. A departure from those expectations may constitute oppression where the resulting conduct is sufficiently unfair or prejudicial.
Justice Caldwell found that Johnson reasonably expected the company’s properties or their sale proceeds to be used substantially toward redeeming his preferred shares. That expectation was supported by the restructuring arrangements, redemption provisions and repeated assurances concerning payments following property sales. Diverting the proceeds to businesses controlled by the respondents, while leaving the preferred shares substantially unredeemed, violated those expectations.
Why the Directors Faced Personal Liability
The Court applied the principles established in Wilson v. Alharayeri, 2017 SCC 39, which permit personal liability where oppressive conduct is attributable to directors and imposing liability is appropriate. Justice Caldwell found that Blackstock and Murie personally participated in the oppressive conduct, benefited financially and increased their control over the company. Their misuse of corporate power and bad faith justified personal liability.
The Court decided the petition summarily and declared that the company’s affairs had been conducted oppressively and unfairly prejudicially. However, it did not determine the amount payable because the evidence lacked an adequate accounting of outstanding dividends, share redemptions and previous payments. The petitioners were awarded costs, with the outstanding financial calculations left for further consideration.
What Business Sellers and Minority Shareholders Should Take From the Decision
Business owners exchanging equity interests for redeemable preferred shares should carefully document redemption rights and expectations concerning corporate asset sales. Controlling directors cannot assume that maintaining related businesses justifies diverting proceeds at the expense of minority shareholders’ reasonable expectations. ATAC LAW represents business owners, investors and shareholders in commercial litigation and real estate disputes, including shareholder oppression, director liability and disputes involving corporate property assets.


