Infrastructure Law

When Can Government Remove an Encampment? B.C. Court Grants Injunction Over Penticton Road Land

The Supreme Court of British Columbia granted a permanent injunction requiring the removal of Penticton’s Fairview Encampment from provincial highway land. In British Columbia (Ministry of Transportation and Transit) v. Borkristl, 2026 BCSC 2119, the Court found that the continuous occupation constituted trespass, public nuisance and a contravention of the Transportation Act. The Court also rejected the defendants’ section 7 Charter challenge, finding that the evidence did not establish a deprivation of their protected interests arising from removal from this particular location.

Why the Province Sought an Injunction

The Fairview Encampment occupied land legally designated as part of Highway 97 near the Fairview Road intersection. The Province presented evidence of repeated fires, damage to traffic-control infrastructure, blocked maintenance access and hazardous waste accumulation. The Court found that the location presented significant risks to occupants, motorists, emergency responders and the public.

Justice Hardwick concluded that the continued occupation constituted trespass and violated section 62 of the Transportation Act. The Court also found public nuisance because the activities substantially interfered with public safety and access to infrastructure. Given the continuing violations and safety concerns, permanent injunctive relief was appropriate.

Why Alternative Measures Did Not Prevent Removal

The defendants opposed the injunction and proposed safety measures, additional supports and relocation planning. They argued that the Province should address the hazards rather than displace people experiencing homelessness. The Court found that these proposals did not justify refusing the requested injunction.

The Court also held that the Province was not required to exercise discretionary statutory powers to authorize the encampment. Some proposed measures would effectively require mandatory orders directing government action and expenditure, engaging restrictions under the Crown Proceeding Act. The Court rejected those measures as grounds for denying injunctive relief in these proceedings.

Why Section 7 of the Charter Was Not Engaged

The defendants argued that displacement would increase risks to their life, liberty and security of the person. They raised concerns about violence, exposure, disrupted services, psychological harm and loss of community support. The Court acknowledged those concerns but found insufficient evidence connecting removal from this specific site to a material increase in the relevant risks.

Justice Hardwick distinguished earlier decisions involving blanket restrictions on temporary overnight sheltering where practical alternatives were unavailable. The proposed injunction concerned continuous occupation of one highway property, while qualifying overnight sheltering remained legally permitted in other public spaces under Penticton’s bylaws. The Court concluded that the defendants had not established a deprivation of their section 7 interests and therefore did not address the principles of fundamental justice.

What the Court Ordered

The Court required occupants to vacate the property and remove their structures by noon on October 30, 2026. Provincial personnel were authorized to remove remaining structures, and police could arrest and remove persons reasonably believed to be obstructing those activities. The defendants’ cross-application was dismissed, and each party was ordered to bear its own costs.

What Public Authorities and Property Owners Should Take From the Decision

The ruling does not establish a general right for governments to remove encampments from public land. Its outcome depended on the property’s statutory designation, documented safety hazards, available lawful overnight-sheltering options and the evidence concerning displacement-related harm. Similar disputes require a case-specific assessment of statutory powers, constitutional rights and injunctive relief.

ATAC LAW represents parties in infrastructure law and civil litigation. These matters may involve public land, statutory powers, competing legal interests and injunctions. The firm advises on the applicable legal framework and the evidence required to pursue or defend court proceedings.

Related content

More legal insights and practical guidance from our team.

View all
vancouver aquatic centre redesign juidicial review Infrastructure Law

Can a City Redesign a Voter-Approved Infrastructure Project? B.C. Court Upholds Vancouver Aquatic Centre Changes

The Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed a challenge to Vancouver’s decision to replace the Vancouver Aquatic Centre with a facility containing…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
Patullo bridge engineering arbitration Surrey, BC Construction Law

Pattullo Bridge Arbitration: B.C. Court Refuses Appeal of $4.94 Million Design Award

The British Columbia Court of Appeal refused a contractor’s application to appeal an arbitration award arising from engineering design errors on the…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator
bc dam repair liability Commercial Real Estate and Disputes

Court Rules Province Had No Duty to Warn Property Buyers of Alleged Dam Defects

The British Columbia Court of Appeal upheld the striking of a negligence claim against the Province for allegedly failing to warn property…

Mike Stewart, P.Eng., Partner, Construction Lawyer, Mediator & Arbitrator